What Shoe Retailers Need to Measure (But Don’t)

24 June 2025

Retail decisions will always be part gut. Dan Holman, owner of Retail by CRS and coach behind The Wealthy Retailer, says data is how you find out whether your gut was right. Early on, he was sure one vendor was his best: a million dollars a year in sales. The data showed he was spending $800,000 at cost to get it, and it was choking his cash.

Measure against your plan, not last year

Every game has a scoreboard. In retail, the score is measured against your own plan. Dan doesn’t compare this year’s sales to last year’s. He tracks the numbers that create sales:

  • Traffic: how many people walk in
  • Conversion: how many of them buy
  • Average sale: how much each buyer spends

Multiply them and you get sales. If 18 people come in on a Monday, half buy and they spend $50 each, that’s $450. Now you can predict, and you know which lever to push. Dan watches the last 12 weeks closely. Last year is a reference, not a target.

No door counter? Dan’s answer: if you won’t count traffic, why count sales? A counter costs around $500. Even a tally on paper works, as long as you count the same way every day.

Small levers, real money

Say your average sale is $130 and you want $150. Find a $60 add-on and sell it to one customer in three. Over 100 sales, that’s $2,000 more in a day without more traffic.

Conversion comes back to a selling system: greet everyone, engage, understand, present a full solution, handle objections, close, and say goodbye. “Just looking” usually means looking to be served.

Inventory is cash on the floor

Dan treats each category as its own business that has to earn its keep. When one lags, he compares it with one that works instead of hunting for what’s wrong. A slow category gets moved and re-presented before it gets marked down.

Watch inventory age. If 80% of your stock is more than 120 days old, customers have already seen it and voted with their wallets. Look at size runs too. Many “too much inventory” problems are really broken size matrices: missing core sizes and too many fringe ones.

And when a $100 shoe has sat for 90 days, marking it to $50 doesn’t lose $50. That money was spent long ago. You get $50 back to invest in what customers actually want. Dan measures retail success in the bank balance, not the income statement.

His tool for Shopify stores, CRS Advanced Responsive Reporting, shows weeks of supply, margin, size drill-downs and inventory age by category.

Connect with Dan: Retail by CRS · The Wealthy Retailer podcast · Instagram · Facebook · LinkedIn

Listen to the episode

Follow The Footwear Retailer on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube. Watch this episode on YouTube.

You May Also Like…

0 Comments